Giving No Quarter to Quarter French

Our evening at Quarter French began with a plant that apparently wanted a seat at the table. The dining room is lovely, with charming bistro details, abundant greenery, and, blessedly, an atmosphere quiet enough to enjoy an actual conversation. Unfortunately, one enormous plant was looming over a dining chair with rather more enthusiasm than we appreciated. We asked to move, and the staff graciously accommodated us. That graciousness would prove to be one of the evening's most consistent pleasures.
The food, unfortunately, was another matter.
We began with roasted radishes, French onion dip, steak tartare, Thai coconut chili mussels, and bread service. It was an ambitious opening, and not an especially successful one.
The roasted radishes ($14) were beautifully presented but barely roasted. Hard, with little char or developed sweetness, they sat over a creamy base that tasted more like French onion dip than the actual French onion dip we ordered. The dish was aggressively acidic until we discovered most of the salt lurking underneath the vegetables.

Jason, our culinary authority for the evening, suspected the radishes had been baked and briefly charred rather than properly roasted. His assessment was considerably more direct: just roast the damn things. Nobody at the table disagreed.
The French onion dip wasn't much better. Cream cheese dominated, overwhelming both the onion flavor and the trout roe. The waffle-cut chips were excellent, but the unseasoned vegetables contributed little. And why quarter the raw radishes? How exactly is one supposed to scoop thick dip with a quarter of a radish?

The bread service was a welcome improvement. The rolls were beautifully browned, light and airy inside, although heavily salted on the exterior.

The Thai coconut chili mussels arrived looking gorgeous, arranged around rice in an inviting orange broth. The broth was pleasant, but where was the chili? The mussels themselves were slightly overcooked, and several were gritty.

Then, finally, something worked. The steak tartare ($18) was our first genuinely successful dish. The advertised CHS Wagyu beef was unremarkable, and neither Jason nor the rest of us knew quite what "Charleston Wagyu" meant. But the confit egg yolk was perfectly prepared and made the dish. Mustard provided a smart, sharp counterpoint to the richness. The beef wasn't memorable, but the composition worked, and everyone enjoyed it.

We hoped the main courses would build on that success. They did not.
The $46 bone-in Iberico pork chop au poivre was a particularly painful disappointment. Iberico pork should be tender, rich, and flavorful. Ours was overcooked, tough, and bland. The cognac cream sauce offered little consolation. Despite the presence of whole, softened green peppercorns, there was virtually no pepper flavor.

If I'm chewing actual peppercorns, I expect to taste pepper. I don't think that's an unreasonable burden of proof.
The black grouper special arrived with a gorgeous sear, perched over what was described as a white bean cassoulet. Unfortunately, the beautiful crust concealed dry, overcooked fish with almost no flavor. The promised lemon gremolata was lost entirely.

The cassoulet was worse. Hard white beans, muted leeks, watery broth, undercooked carrots, and a few underseasoned mushrooms. A lighter interpretation of cassoulet is perfectly legitimate, but lightness shouldn't mean an absence of flavor.
By this point, we were beginning to lose hope. And then came the cauliflower. Of all the things on the menu, the $28 cauliflower steak turned out to be the undisputed star of the evening. The cauliflower was perfectly tender inside, with a wonderfully crisp, crunchy exterior. The beluga lentils were soft and earthy. Crème fraîche added silkiness, harissa contributed gentle warmth, and the romesco brought roasted-pepper flavor without overwhelming anything.

Every component had a purpose. Every texture worked. The flavors complemented one another rather than competing. It was excellent. There was considerable irony in finding the evening's finest cooking in a cauliflower steak after watching the kitchen struggle with Iberico pork, black grouper, and mussels. But we give credit where it's due. If the kitchen needed a character witness, the cauliflower was ready to testify. This dish demonstrated precisely the thoughtful cooking we had been looking for all night.
We should have stopped there. Instead, we ordered the Vietnamese coffee caramel beignets ($16). These were so bad that Jason finally said something. The beignets were dense, tough little rocks of dough, difficult to cut and even harder to chew. We've had better fried dough at the fair. Beneath them sat refrigerator-cold caramel tasting overwhelmingly of condensed milk, without the slightest discernible suggestion of Vietnamese coffee. Hot dough on ice-cold caramel made no culinary sense.

Our server, Kat, who had been lovely throughout the evening, asked how we liked dessert.
Jason looked at her and asked, "Do you really want to know?" She did. To her considerable credit, she listened graciously, apologized, and brought over her manager. He was equally gracious, agreed that the ice-cold caramel was a problem, offered to remake the dessert, and removed it from our bill.
This deserves recognition. From accommodating our request to move tables to Kat's attentiveness and the manager's handling of dessert, the front-of-house team demonstrated genuine hospitality. Restaurants make mistakes. What matters is how they respond. Quarter French's staff handled the complaint professionally, without defensiveness or excuses. In mitigation, the evidence of excellent hospitality was compelling.
Unfortunately, the beignets were only the final disappointment in a meal full of them. The beverage program presented another problem. Noel enjoyed her Napoleon Complex, finding the orange more prominent than expected but ultimately well balanced. For those of us seeking sophisticated nonalcoholic options, however, the choices were disappointing. A THC beverage is not an appropriate substitute for a nonintoxicating cocktail, and the maple-sweetened Saintly Lemon Drop held little appeal. I settled for unsweetened iced tea.
And then there's the matter of the restaurant's identity. I have no objection to French cooking incorporating flavors from elsewhere. Some of the world's most exciting food comes from precisely that kind of exchange. But the kitchen needs to bring those influences together with some coherence, and the dishes need to deliver on their descriptions. Here, the Thai coconut chili mussels lacked chili, the Vietnamese coffee caramel lacked coffee, the pork au poivre lacked pepper, and the cassoulet lacked just about everything that makes cassoulet worth eating. The recurring problems weren't simply matters of personal preference. Proteins were overcooked, vegetables and beans undercooked, and seasoning frequently missed the mark. Beautiful presentations repeatedly promised more than the food delivered. The weight of the evidence was difficult to ignore.
Which brings me to Jason's revelation. Toward the end of dinner, after a procession of dishes borrowing from Thailand, Vietnam, North Africa, Spain, and France, he suddenly announced that he'd solved the mystery of the restaurant's name.
"It's Quarter French because only a quarter of the food is French!"
I laughed, but he had a point. Quarter French has a lovely dining room, genuinely gracious staff, and at least one cook who knows how to make cauliflower sing. Unfortunately, on this visit, those considerable virtues couldn't overcome a kitchen that repeatedly failed to execute its own ambitions.
We came hoping for a memorable dinner. We got one, although not for the reasons we'd anticipated.



Comments