top of page
Search

La Cave: Where Hospitality Outperforms the Kitchen

Writer: Alexia Pittas
Alexia Pittas
2 days ago
5 min read

Some restaurants serve extraordinary food in unremarkable surroundings. Others make you feel like an honored guest while the kitchen struggles to keep up. La Cave, the stylish French sister restaurant to Felix in downtown Charleston, gave us a lovely evening. Whether the food lived up to the hospitality was another question.


A Beautiful Room and a Charming Advocate


La Cave is beautifully appointed, with comfortable seating and an atmosphere that manages to feel sophisticated without being stuffy. I found the dining room uncomfortably warm, although nobody else seemed troubled, so perhaps that particular objection belongs to me alone.


Parking, often the first challenge of a downtown Charleston dinner, was refreshingly easy. Street parking, paid lots, and garages are all readily available nearby.


Our server, Nehemiah, was an absolute delight. Charming, knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely enthusiastic about the menu, he offered thoughtful recommendations throughout the evening.


I was particularly pleased that La Cave had two nonalcoholic cocktail options, although they do not appear on the beverage menu and I had to ask about them. At Nehemiah's suggestion, I tried a cocktail featuring the restaurant's house-made nonalcoholic gin, apple, soda water, mint, and a whisper of nutmeg. It was marvelous.


The nutmeg contributed just enough warmth to make the drink feel distinctly autumnal, while the apple and mint kept it bright and refreshing. Most importantly, it wasn't sweet. At a time when far too many mocktails resemble fruit juice dressed up for a night out, this was a sophisticated adult beverage that happened not to contain alcohol. I ordered another.


My dear friend was equally content with her two glasses of Côtes du Rhône. The evening was off to a promising start.


The Quail Makes an Excellent Opening Argument


La Cave had introduced its fall menu just two days before our visit, and both Nehemiah and I thought the quail lollipops sounded particularly appealing. We were right. The quail arrived beautifully presented, the bones serving as convenient little handles. The exterior was wonderfully crisp, while the meat inside remained succulent and full of flavor.



But what elevated the dish from good to exceptional were the accompaniments. The pickled grapes provided a delightful sweet-sour contrast to the richness of the fried quail. Pickled fennel contributed another layer of brightness, while the lightly dressed greens kept the whole preparation lively rather than heavy. Every element had a purpose, and nothing overwhelmed anything else.

I've never considered myself particularly fond of poultry, but quail has been making a remarkably persuasive case lately. Between Honeysuckle Rose, Estadio, and now La Cave, I may have to reconsider my longstanding prejudice.


The quail lollipops were easily the best savory dish of the evening. At $24, they weren't inexpensive, but the quality and thoughtful composition justified the price.


The Tenderloin Tartine: Assault With Deadly Chili


Our second appetizer was the $27 filet mignon tartine, featuring tenderloin, local mushrooms, ricotta, and hot honey over toasted bread. Nehemiah recommended it enthusiastically, explaining that the honey provided just a gentle touch of heat to lift the other ingredients. It sounded lovely.


What arrived was a beautiful-looking dish with an unfortunate secret. The first bite delivered an immediate, overwhelming blast of chili heat. There was no opportunity to appreciate the tenderloin, mushrooms, or ricotta. The chili had seized control of the proceedings and refused to yield the floor.


We both disliked it immediately. We ultimately removed the tenderloin from the tartine and ate it separately. Freed from its fiery captor, the beef was acceptable, although cooked to medium rather than the rare preparation I would have preferred. The combination of creamy ricotta, savory mushrooms, tender beef, and restrained hot honey held considerable promise, but the excessive heat defeated it.


We explained our disappointment to Nehemiah, who was genuinely concerned. Rather than offering a perfunctory apology, he took the matter directly to the kitchen and management. They tasted the dish themselves. And they agreed with us. Apparently, the kitchen had recently changed the chili or increased its intensity, with unintended consequences. The staff acknowledged that the heat was excessive, apologized sincerely, and assured us that the preparation would be corrected. They also removed the tartine from our bill. This was hospitality at its finest. Restaurants make mistakes. What distinguishes a good establishment is how it responds when those mistakes are brought to its attention. La Cave accepted responsibility immediately, without defensiveness or excuses. The kitchen conceded the point and made restitution.


I hope the revised tartine lives up to its original promise.


The Whole Snapper: An Impressive Appearance, a Weak Case


For our main course, we shared the whole local red snapper, served with piperade, herb butter, and grilled vegetables. I love a whole fish, particularly when the head remains intact. The cheeks and eyeballs are among my favorite morsels, and my charming friend was more than happy to relinquish her interest in those particular assets.



The fish was deboned, which made sharing it easy, and its presentation was impressive. Unfortunately, the flavor didn't match the appearance. The snapper was slightly overcooked, leaving the flesh drier than it should have been. The accompanying piperade, a traditional Basque preparation of peppers, onions, and tomatoes, contributed surprisingly little flavor. Nor did the herb butter provide the richness or moisture the fish needed.


The most compelling elements on the board were the grilled vegetables. Shishito peppers, zucchini, and onions had developed a lovely char, bringing smokiness and depth that the fish itself lacked. When the supporting cast consistently outperforms the leading actor, there may be a problem with the production.


I thoroughly enjoyed the cheeks and eyeballs, but even those small pleasures couldn't transform the snapper into a memorable dish. My friend agreed. It was perfectly adequate, but neither of us felt any particular desire to order it again.


Dessert: Evidence in Mitigation


Fortunately, dessert restored some of our enthusiasm. I chose the apple clafoutis, an intriguing preparation featuring apple compote, savory St. Angel cheese, crème anglaise, and cookie crumble. When it arrived, its pronounced sugary aroma made me worry that I had ordered something far sweeter than I wanted. I was mistaken.



The clafoutis was freshly prepared to order, warm and beautifully cooked. The apple was present without dominating, and the silky St. Angel cheese introduced a lovely savory quality that prevented the dessert from becoming cloying. The crème anglaise was delicate and delicious, while the crumble provided a welcome textural contrast. This was precisely the sort of dessert I enjoy: interesting, carefully balanced, and restrained enough to allow the individual ingredients to shine.


My friend ordered the gâteau au chocolat with salted caramel sorbet and pronounced it delicious, particularly praising the sorbet. Because she was nursing a cold, we weren't sharing food that evening, so I cannot offer independent testimony on her dessert. Her assessment, however, was unequivocally favorable and she ate the entire serving.



I enjoyed a single espresso with mine, a small indulgence that seemed entirely appropriate.

La Cave also knew we were celebrating my birthday month and thoughtfully presented my dessert with a candle and warm wishes. It was a lovely gesture, made all the more meaningful by the genuine warmth of the service throughout our visit.


The Bill and the Verdict


Our evening came to approximately $240 for two, including a 20 percent gratuity, after the tartine had been removed from the bill. We had enjoyed two appetizers, one shared main course, two desserts, two glasses of wine, two nonalcoholic cocktails, and an espresso, although we were charged for only one appetizer. The price wasn't outrageous for downtown Charleston, but neither was it a bargain given the uneven cooking.


The quail and clafoutis demonstrated genuine culinary skill. The tartine and snapper demonstrated a troubling lack of consistency. Meanwhile, Nehemiah and his colleagues provided gracious, attentive hospitality throughout, handling our complaint with professionalism and warmth.


We had a wonderful evening, but when I asked whether my friend would return, her answer mirrored my own. She wouldn't object if someone else wanted to go, but she wouldn't be making another reservation herself. That seems about right.


The final ruling? La Cave's hospitality is beyond reproach, and its quail and clafoutis deserve commendations. But the kitchen's performance was too inconsistent to earn an enthusiastic recommendation.

 
 
 

Comments


Join us for delicious updates.

Charleston, South Carolina

  • Instagram

Get new blog posts by email.

LexLociDelicious.com

© 2035 by LexLociDelicious.com. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page