top of page
Search

When Rebranding Makes Sense for Everyone

Writer: Alexia Pittas
Alexia Pittas
7 days ago
8 min read

For years, Southbound was a point of culinary disagreement between my son George and me. George loved it. I was less enthusiastic.


The original Southbound celebrated live-fire cooking and an assortment of proteins, including game meats that don't appear on every Charleston menu. George, a purist at heart, thought this was marvelous. Give him an excellent piece of meat, cook it properly over an open flame, and he was a happy man. I wanted more. To my mind, putting an expensive or unusual piece of meat over a fire is not, by itself, particularly creative. Elk, bison, beef, whatever. A good fire and a good protein can produce an excellent dinner, but I want to see what a chef can do beyond the obvious. I want imagination, balance, and a reason for the other ingredients on the plate to be there. Southbound's original concept never quite delivered that for me.


Oh but Southbound has changed. The restaurant has refreshed its décor, substantially rewritten its menu, and embraced a new identity as a steakhouse. George was eager to investigate. I was willing to reconsider the evidence. By the end of dinner, I was prepared to enter a verdict he had been waiting years to hear. Southbound had won me over.


The Case for Restraint


Our evening began with a bit of tableside theater, courtesy of Southbound's chef-owner, who personally prepared our beef tartare. It was a lovely presentation. As she combined the dry-aged beef with smoked egg aioli, cornichon, pickled mustard seeds, egg yolk, and Maldon salt, she explained each component and its contribution to the dish.



I watched with considerable interest, although I confess I was tempted to interrupt the proceedings with a question. Where was the horseradish? But rather than challenge the chef's judgment before tasting the evidence, I decided to reserve my objection. This was a wise decision.


The beef was exceptional, and the preparation demonstrated precisely why restraint can be more valuable than another assertive ingredient. The seasonings complemented the beef without competing with it. Horseradish, which I ordinarily welcome in tartare, might well have overwhelmed what made this particular beef worth celebrating.


I especially appreciated the texture. Rather than being finely minced, the beef was cut into small, distinct chunks, giving each bite satisfying substance and allowing the quality of the meat to speak for itself. Sometimes the most impressive thing a chef can do is know what to leave out.


Foie Gras Without the Sugar Rush


The seared foie gras arrived with parsnip and pear soubise, fig jam, and brioche toast. On paper, that combination suggested a dish that might lean heavily toward sweetness. It didn't.

In fact, I could barely distinguish the fig, and I was pleasantly surprised by how restrained the preparation was.



Most importantly, the foie gras was allowed to taste like liver. It retained that distinctive mineral quality that makes foie gras so compelling, while delivering the luscious, silky richness that makes it such an indulgence. The accompaniments supported the foie gras rather than competing with it.


After the tartare, this was another demonstration that restraint is not the absence of creativity.


The Octopus Makes the Case


If the tartare demonstrated restraint and the foie gras respected the character of its principal ingredient, the grilled Spanish octopus demonstrated something even more impressive: the ability to make several distinctive ingredients work together without sacrificing what made each one interesting. The octopus had a lovely char that stopped short of disrespect. Beneath it were sea island red peas, grilled Swiss chard, and a chorizo vinaigrette.


The octopus was tender and naturally sweet. The field peas brought an earthy nuttiness, while the Swiss chard contributed its own earthiness and a pleasant bitterness. Each ingredient had something different to say. The chorizo vinaigrette brought the conversation together.



With just a suggestion of heat, it amplified the flavors of all three components without overwhelming any of them. The sweetness of the octopus became more apparent, the nuttiness of the peas more compelling, and the bitterness of the chard an asset rather than a distraction. Nothing was competing for attention. Nothing disappeared into the sauce. This was a very smart dish. This was my favorite dish of the evening.


It also illustrated what I had been missing from Southbound's original concept. Fire and an excellent protein can produce a delicious meal. But understanding how to build a plate in which every ingredient contributes something essential is an entirely different level of cooking. Southbound had found that level.


The $72 Cheesesteak Goes on Trial


George ordered the $72 wood-fired Wagyu cheesesteak. Before anyone starts sharpening pitchforks over a $72 sandwich, let me be clear. The ingredients were excellent, the beef was beautifully cooked, and George thoroughly enjoyed eating it. I tried a bite myself and was particularly taken with the Gruyère cheese whiz.


But George had an objection. It wasn't a cheesesteak. His argument was that the genius of a cheesesteak lies in taking a relatively humble cut of beef, shaving or slicing it thinly, and preparing it in a way that transforms it into something delicious. Southbound's version used substantial chunks of excellent Wagyu beef instead. That, George argued, makes it an excellent steak sandwich, not a cheesesteak. I think he has a point but I am hardly an expert.



He also would have liked a more generous presence of foie gras. If you're going to embrace extravagance, there is something to be said for committing fully to the enterprise. Neither of us thought the sandwich was poorly executed. George understood the price given the quality of the ingredients. He simply wasn't convinced he needed to order it again. And therein lies an interesting distinction. The cheesesteak took expensive, luxurious ingredients and produced an excellent sandwich. The octopus took comparatively modest ingredients and produced something extraordinary. Luxury and culinary sophistication are not necessarily the same thing.


Southbound's kitchen is clearly capable of both, but I found its imagination considerably more compelling than its extravagance.


A New Champion in the Filet Division


When I visit a steakhouse, I am almost invariably going to order the filet. I know there are people who insist that ribeye is the superior cut, that a strip has more character, and that filet lacks sufficient fat to deliver the best beef flavor. They are entitled to their opinions. I am entitled to my filet.


Until this dinner, I would have told you that Marbled & Fin served the best filet in Charleston. That title now belongs to Southbound. The steak was magnificent. It arrived with a beautifully developed exterior crust, a generous application of salt, and an interior so tender that it practically melted in my mouth. It was cooked precisely as I wanted it, with the exterior providing texture and flavor without compromising the tenderness of the beef.



Alongside it was an entire grilled head of garlic, allowing me to squeeze out as much of that luscious roasted garlic as I wished. This was not a steak that needed rescuing with elaborate sauces or extravagant garnishes. It was an exceptional piece of beef, expertly prepared.

And that is exactly what a steakhouse should deliver.


Because sometimes a girl wants to be fancy, I ordered the Oscar preparation with asparagus, lump crab meat, and hollandaise. The asparagus was grilled and cooked through while retaining its fresh firmness. It didn't have a particularly pronounced char, but the preparation was excellent. The crab meat was perfectly pleasant, although it was the hollandaise that made the dish sing. The sauce was lovely, with just enough citrus to brighten the richness without overwhelming it. A bite combining steak, asparagus, crab, and that beautifully balanced hollandaise was genuinely luxurious. By this point, I was getting quite full, so George became the beneficiary of much of the remaining asparagus. He did not object.


The Humble Side that Stole the Show


We also ordered the beef fat Lyonnaise potatoes. They were flavorful, satisfying, and entirely respectable. They were also largely unnecessary to the meal. The corn custard brûlée, however, was another matter entirely. This unassuming side featured whole kernels of corn set in a pudding-like custard, topped with cornbread, and baked. It sounds like the sort of dish that might appear at a church supper. It tasted like something that deserved a considerably more prestigious appointment.



Sweet and savory, comforting yet surprisingly compelling, it was one of the most delightful surprises of the evening. I managed only a couple of bites. George ate the rest. For a restaurant built around premium proteins, it is worth observing that one of the most memorable offerings was a humble dish of corn.


An Unexpected Victory for the Ivan Drago


George was serving as our cocktail investigator for the evening, a role usually occupied by his sister, Noel. He took his responsibilities seriously and ordered three cocktails.


The first was a pineapple daiquiri, which he enjoyed. Because of my pineapple allergy, I did not participate in that particular investigation. The second was a drink neither of us would ordinarily have considered ordering. The Ivan Drago. Vodka. Beet juice. Ginger beer. White balsamic vinegar. I dislike ginger beer. George dislikes ginger beer. And the combination sounded, frankly, rather dreadful. But we saw the cocktail delivered to a nearby table, where its appearance caught our attention. Our server explained that the white balsamic vinegar was the finishing touch that brought the drink together and encouraged George to try it. He did. And it was one of the best cocktails I have ever tasted.


The surprise was its balance. Despite the beet juice and ginger beer, the drink was not particularly sweet. The beet contributed a subtle earthiness, while the white balsamic supplied acidity that kept the entire concoction light, refreshing, and remarkably harmonious.

It was a cocktail whose ingredients seemed unlikely companions but proved extraordinarily compatible.


George's third cocktail was a rum concoction with a pronounced alcoholic character. He enjoyed it. I took one sip and declined further participation. I cannot fairly assess its balance from that limited taste.


As for nonalcoholic offerings, I didn't explore the menu. When I arrived at the table, a glass of unsweetened tea was already waiting for me, and it was replenished throughout the evening without my having to ask. That sort of attentive hospitality deserves recognition, even if it leaves the nonalcoholic cocktail program for a future investigation.



A Sidewalk Jury Delivers its Verdict


As George and I left the restaurant, we found ourselves walking along a downtown Charleston street with another couple who had also just finished dinner. They were discussing their meal. Naturally, I couldn't resist.


"Did you just leave Southbound?" I asked. They had. And what did they think? They had loved it too. The woman had ordered the beet salad, which she described enthusiastically. Her husband, who ordinarily dislikes beets, enjoyed it too. They were equally enthusiastic about their mains. She had ordered the short ribs, while he had chosen a steak. But what interested me most was their history with the restaurant. She had never been before and was delighted with the experience. He had visited Southbound under its previous concept and, like me, had not been particularly impressed. Now he was eager to return.


Here we were, four people walking to our cars after dinner, discovering that two former Southbound skeptics had independently reached the same conclusion. The restaurant had changed, and the change was for the better. No formal polling. No scientific sampling. Just a spontaneous conversation among diners who had really enjoyed their evening. Sometimes the most interesting evidence presents itself outside the courtroom.


The Verdict


Southbound's transformation into a steakhouse is more than a change of décor and menu. At least on the evidence of our dinner, it represents a more thoughtful, creative, and satisfying approach to cooking. The kitchen has retained its respect for excellent proteins while demonstrating a greater willingness to develop complex, balanced dishes around them.


The service was attentive. The cocktails showed imagination. The filet was the best I have had in Charleston. And the octopus and corn custard reminded me that the most memorable dishes are not necessarily the most expensive.


George, who loved the original Southbound, is already asking when we can return (though he is also asking me to file a motion with Chef for the return of their original sweetbread offering which no longer appears on the menu.)


In fact, he is now insisting that his birthday dinner take place there, rather than at Honeysuckle Rose or anywhere else in Charleston. For anyone familiar with George's devotion to excellent food, that is a formidable endorsement.


As for me, I am recruiting reinforcements for our next visit. There are still elk steaks to investigate, a beet salad to consider, and a French onion soup that allegedly deserves a full investigation. For once, George and I are in complete agreement.


Southbound's rebranding makes sense. And, more importantly, it tastes delicious.

 
 
 

Comments


Join us for delicious updates.

Charleston, South Carolina

  • Instagram

Get new blog posts by email.

LexLociDelicious.com

© 2035 by LexLociDelicious.com. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page