top of page
Search

The Archer Misses the Mark

Writer: Alexia Pittas
Alexia Pittas
Sep 16
4 min read

The Archer came highly recommended. Our hosts had been dying to take us, and their enthusiasm was infectious. By the end of the evening, however, the best things about the meal were the company and the parking.


The parking really is excellent. The Archer offers two free hours in the attached garage, an almost mythical amenity in downtown Charleston. You scan the code on the menu, register your license plate, and walk a short distance to the restaurant. It was easy, convenient, and flawlessly executed.


Unfortunately, the parking garage does not operate the kitchen.


The restaurant itself was uncomfortably hot, and the chairs seemed designed to discourage anyone from staying long enough to discover how many things could go wrong. Both the cocktails and nonalcoholic cocktails were small and thoroughly mediocre. At $15 and $12 respectively, they needed to deliver something more memorable than an undersized glass and a collective shrug.


We ordered three appetizers and three main courses. The kitchen apparently decided the appetizers were optional. None arrived before the mains. Only after the entrées were already on the table did we ask what had happened. The restaurant apologized and appropriately removed the appetizers from the bill. That was the correct response, and they deserve credit for making it without argument. It did not, however, restore the intended progression of the meal or inspire confidence in what might emerge next.


We cancelled the yellowfin tuna. After smelling the tilefish, ordering more fish from this kitchen felt less like optimism and more like reckless disregard.


The other two appetizers eventually appeared. Neither was worth the wait.


The watermelon elote was edible but underseasoned. Watermelon needs salt to sharpen its sweetness, particularly in a savory preparation. The mild cheese supplied none of the necessary contrast, leaving the dish flat and oddly pointless. We tried it. We did not finish it.



The steak tartare was worse. The beef was cut too coarsely and buried under far too much peppercorn aioli. There was a promising horseradish bite struggling for relevance, but the mayonnaise smothered it. Tartare should showcase the flavor and texture of good beef. This one treated the beef as an inconvenient delivery system for mayo. We did not finish it either.



The golden tilefish announced itself by smell before it reached the table. Fish should not enter a room before the plate does.



The fillet was properly cooked, proving that technical competence and an enjoyable dinner are not the same thing. It was underseasoned and distinctly fishy. The collard-green slaw underneath was genuinely tasty and worked heroically to save the plate, but it had been assigned an impossible task. Cutesy radish cutouts and crispy sweet-potato decorations added color but no useful flavor or texture. Arts and crafts are not seasoning. We left much of the dish behind.


The Archer burger is reportedly one of the restaurant’s signature dishes. It was acceptable, which is not much of an endorsement for a $25 hamburger. The patty was nearly drowned beneath an absurd quantity of Parmesan cream. A sauce should complement a burger, not attempt to conceal it from witnesses. The shoestring fries were nicely cooked, but the avalanche served alongside the burger turned generosity into evidence that nobody in the kitchen knows when to stop. We did not finish that plate either.



The duck breast looked beautiful. Photographs, as it turns out, are not subject to cross-examination. The meat was tough, fatty, and underseasoned. The accompanying farro and arugula salad was fine, once again leaving the supporting element to outperform the protein it was meant to accompany. That plate also went unfinished.



At this point, every savory dish we had ordered remained partially on the table. This was not subtle feedback. The plates were practically submitting affidavits.


The presentation reflected the same lack of discipline. Rustic tavern food need not arrive with tweezers and geometric precision, but it should still look intentional. These plates looked dumped, drowned, scattered, or buried. The tilefish disappeared beneath a thicket of greens and randomly distributed garnishes. The duck shared its plate with a heavy puddle of sauce and an untidy heap of farro. The watermelon looked as though its toppings had been applied from across the room. The burger was engulfed in Parmesan cream and marooned in a sea of fries. Even the successful bread pudding arrived beside a whipped-cream monument large enough to require its own zoning permit. Calling the plating “rustic” would be generous. It was all sloppy.


The bread pudding was the evening’s sole unequivocal culinary success. Everyone who tried it loved it. I did not taste it. By then, the kitchen had exhausted my willingness to gamble on another bite. Still, the table’s verdict was unanimous, and the dessert deserves full credit.



One disappointing dish can be attributed to personal taste. Two may reflect unfortunate ordering. A table full of unfinished plates is a pattern. The failures were not esoteric matters that only an insufferable food critic would notice. The food was underseasoned. The fish smelled fishy. The duck was tough and fatty. The tartare was overwhelmed by mayonnaise. The burger was smothered in cheese sauce. The appetizers were forgotten until after the mains arrived. The room was hot. The chairs were uncomfortable. The drinks were small and forgettable.


The restaurant apologized and comped the forgotten appetizers. The collard-green slaw was good. The fries were well cooked. The bread pudding apparently succeeded. Most importantly, our hosts were wonderful company and salvaged an evening the restaurant seemed determined to sink.


The Archer’s website declares, “All Bullseye. No BS.” That is an ambitious claim for a restaurant that missed nearly every target placed in front of it.


The parking, though, was outstanding.


 
 
 

Comments


Join us for delicious updates.

Charleston, South Carolina

  • Instagram

Get new blog posts by email.

LexLociDelicious.com

© 2035 by LexLociDelicious.com. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page